Mumbai Thoughts >> I hate the extremely high cost of living of Mumbai ☹ : Piyush R.    |    I hate the stressfull life of Mumbai ☹ : Srinibas P.    |    I love that Mumbai is a financial innovation capital : Jimmy P.    |    I love that Mumbai always stand united : Aarti G.    |    I love that Mumbai never sleeps : Rashair C.    |    I hate the lack of nature in Mumbai ☹ : Brinda M.    |    I hate to see homeless people in Mumbai ☹ : Lester M.    |    I love the vibes of Mumbai : Devanshu    |    I hate the uncleanliness of Mumbai ☹ : Devanshu    |    I hate that Mumbai is pedestrian unfriendly ☹ : Milesh S.    |    I love the better employment opportunities of Mumbai : Raza A.    |    I hate the non provision for cyclists in Mumbai ☹ : Asheen A.    |    I love the cultural diversity of Mumbai : Cherylann M.    |    I love that Mumbai is a safe place for women : Madhu G.    |    I hate the lack of gardens in Mumbai ☹ : Madhu G.    |    I love the colonial areas of Mumbai : Milesh S.    |    I hate the poorly maintained heritage buildings of Mumbai ☹ : Krupa T.    |    I hate the noise in Mumbai ☹ : Pradeep M.    |    I love the speed of Mumbai : Pratik C.    |    I love that Mumbai is a land of opportunities : Madhu G.    |    I hate the inadequate public transport infrastructures of Mumbai ☹ : Saurabh K.    |    I love that there is so many things to for entertainment in Mumbai : Saurabh K.    |    I hate the unnecessary honking on the streets of Mumbai ☹ : Krupa T.    |    I love the street food of Mumbai : Jessica N.    |    I love the fast life of Mumbai : Manpreet    |    I hate the crowded trains of Mumbai ☹ : Raza A.    |    I hate the dirty beaches of Mumbai ☹ : Priyesh Y.    |    I love that it never gets too cold in Mumbai : Kshipra L.    |    I love the cosmopolitan culture of Mumbai : Sarit P.    |    I love the honestly of daba walas in Mumbai : Kiran M.    |    I hate the bad civic amenities of Mumbai ☹ : Afrid W.    |    I love that Mumbai is being the financial capital of India : Sanjay B.    |    I hate the lack of proper urban planning in Mumbai ☹ : Manpreet    |    I love the nightlife of Mumbai : Aditi R.    |    I love the helpfull population of Mumbai : Riddhi S.    |    I love that Mumbai is home to so many people and cultures : Arjun M.    |    I hate the noise pollution of Mumbai ☹ : Radhika P.    |    I hate the infrastructures of Mumbai ☹ : Rashair C.    |    I love the vibrant life of Mumbai : Afrid W.    |    I hate the price of real-estate in Mumbai ☹ : Cherylann M.    |    I hate the dirt of Mumbai ☹ : Madhu G.    |    I love the good educational facilities of Mumbai : Stanlay B.    |    I hate the dirt of Mumbai ☹ : Aditi R.    |    I hate the roads potholes of Mumbai ☹ : Arjun M.    |    I hate dirty politics of Mumbai ☹ : Imran S.    |    I hate the corruption of Mumbai ☹ : Arjun M.    |    I hate the sense of filth in Mumbai ☹ : Sunishi G.    |    I love that Mumbai is a city of dreams : Yogita S.    |    I love the great restaurants of Mumbai : Radhika P.    |    I hate the unclean nature of Mumbai ☹ : Sarit P.    |    I love the sea-link in Mumbai : Abhijit    |    I love that people from different cultures live and work together in Mumbai : Saurabh K.    |    I love the inclusive nature of Mumbaikars : Sunishi G.    |    I love Mumbai coastline : Hitesh K.    |    I love the social life of Mumbai : Lester M.    |    I hate the behaviour of government people in Mumbai ☹ : Milan N.    |    I love the old British colonial architecture of Mumbai : Krupa T.    |    I hate the poor drainage system of Mumbai ☹ : Irsad S.    |    I love the diversity of Mumbai : Manish M.    |    I love the culture opportunities of Mumbai : Dupa P.    |    I love the Neo Gothic structures of Mumbai : Faiyar S.    |    I love vada pav in Mumbai : Priyesh Y.    |    I hate the transportation system of Mumbai ☹ : Aarti G.    |    I hate the lack of ecofriendliness of Mumbai ☹ : Manpreet    |    I love the liveliness of Mumbai : Sanjay B.    |    I hate the lack of open spaces in Mumbai ☹ : Anthony D.    |    I love the safety of Mumbai : Radhika P.    |    I love sunset at beach in Mumbai : Jayant V.    |    I hate that people are not following traffic rules in Mumbai ☹ : Komal S.    |    I love Marine Drive in Mumbai : Krupa T.    |    I love the traditions of Mumbai : Dhaval C.    |    I love the beach of Mumbai : Irsad S.    |    I love the sea in Mumbai : Pradeep M.    |    I love the festival in Mumbai : Abhijit    |    I hate the long time of commuting in Mumbai ☹ : Radhika P.    |    I love that Mumbai knowshow to welcome festival : Aarti G.    |    I love the night life of Mumbai : Satish    |    I love the holy songs singing in the train in Mumbai : Abhijit    |    I hate the lack of recreational areas in Mumbai ☹ : Tehsin L.    |    

Woman Gets Treated For Bad Gallbladder In Mumbai Hospital Despite Not Having One

  • |
  • BHC Team

Amongst all the rare and bizarre occurrences in the city of Mumbai is story of German national Teresa Poehlmann. Ms. Poehlmann issued a complaint with the Maharashtra Medical Council with the issue of wrongful treatment. When she felt acute pain in her abdominal region, she admitted herself into the Holy Family Hospital, Bandra to conduct some tests.

The not-so-comical matter is best explained in Teresa Poehlmann's words- "I checked into the Holy Family Hospital on November 23 after experiencing a sudden, unbearable pain in the abdomen. I was attended to by Dr Bryan Sodder, who recommended that I get admitted as he suspected kidney stones or a pancreatic inflation. After a series of tests, including an ultra-sonography, they told me my gallbladder was functioning fine and I was like, ‘where did you find one?"

Poehlmann said. She said that her gallbladder had been removed in a German hospital after stones had formed in the organ. "I had told them at the time of admission that I didn't have a gallbladder. It was mentioned while they noted down my medical history. Despite this, they prescribed medicines to remove gallbladder stones. I was so scared, I took discharge despite doctors trying to convince me to stay," she said.

In light of these recent developments, the hospital has issued an apology to Ms. Poehlmann, in spite of her complaint to the Medical Council. In the issued apology letter, the hospital blames the error on a printing mistake, bearing the signature of Dr. Veena Louzado, the head of the Radiology Department. It said, "The print report was pre-formatted and they did not remove the gallbladder part from the paragraph."

When asked, the hospital's medical director, Dr. Amida Fernandez also blamed the printing error for the mishap. To be more specific, she was quoted as saying, "after the patient complained, I personally inquired and found that the error was made by a clerk in the Imaging Department. All our reports are printed on preformatted sheets and the clerk should have removed the mention of gallbladder. We immediately rectified the error and issued a fresh report. There is no question of wrong medication as the patient took discharge from the hospital even before the treatment could start. It was a human error, and we ensure best possible treatment for all our patients."

While the repercussions of this mistake remain to be seen, the whole incident reveals the chaotic nature in which our hospitals are run. To treat a woman for a gallbladder issue, when she doesn't have a gallbladder in her body, is a funny enough notion until you consider the possibility of the same occurring with a more serious issue. And pardon me for being biased in my rhetoric, but, I don't really buy the whole printing error story. Surely, a hospital should be held to higher standards? It's not like our lives are at stake here. Oh wait, they are.